WWW.THESIS.DISLIB.INFO
FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Online materials, documents
 
<< HOME
CONTACTS



Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |

«Document hosted at WRONGFUL SELECTION: ASSISTED REPRODUCTIVE ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Document hosted at

http://www.jdsupra.com/post/documentViewer.aspx?fid=5c86444b-0507-409d-96c5-36818102f8d1

WRONGFUL SELECTION: ASSISTED REPRODUCTIVE

TECHNOLOGIES, INTENTIONAL DIMINISHMENT, AND THE

PROCREATIVE RIGHT

ALEXANDER D. WOLFE∗

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. INTRODUCTION

A. The Landscape of Reproductive Issues

B. A Survey of In-Vitro Fertilization and Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis

II. THE MORAL, ETHICAL, AND LEGAL ISSUES SURROUNDING THE USE OF

PREIMPLANTATION GENETIC DIAGNOSIS TO SELECT FOR GENETIC

CHARACTERISTICS

A. The Legal Background

B. The Implications of Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis and Intentional Diminishment: Arguments For and Against Strict Regulation

III. OPTIONS TOWARD REGULATING THE USE OF PREIMPLANTATION GENETIC

DIAGNOSIS TO INTENTIONALLY CREATE DISABLED CHILDREN

A. Federal Regulation

B. State Legislation

C. Methods of Regulation Not Involving State Intervention

IV. CONCLUSION

The author attended Catholic University’s Columbus School of Law from 2004 to 2005 and graduated ∗ from the Texas Wesleyan School of Law in 2007.

Document hosted at http://www.jdsupra.com/post/documentViewer.aspx?fid=5c86444b-0507-409d-96c5-36818102f8d1 I. Introduction [I]n the realm of bioethics, the evils we face (if indeed they are evils) are intertwined with the goods we so keenly seek: cures for disease, relief of suffering, preservation of life. Distinguishing good and bad thus intermixed is often extremely difficult.1

–  –  –

The science of reproduction has advanced dramatically in the last several decades.

Whereas in the past, couples experiencing difficulty producing children of their own had little or no recourse beyond adoption, couples today enjoy an array of choices thanks to various assisted-reproductive technologies (ART), from injections or pills designed to stimulate the body’s own reproductive capabilities,2 to the use of in-vitro fertilization (IVF) techniques to produce viable embryos outside of the body for implantation into the mother,3 to the use of a surrogate mother to carry an embryo,4 or to the use of sperm from a surrogate father to create a fertilized embryo.5 Incredibly, it is even possible to utilize all of these methods at once by conceiving a child utilizing a donated egg and sperm and implanting the resulting fertilized egg into the uterus of a surrogate mother.6 Today, these are relatively common and uncontroversial techniques for creating life. Techniques are now being perfected that lie at the very frontiers of medicine, such as the use of preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) to select for or against certain Leon R. Kass, Chairman, President’s Council on Bioethics, Opening Remarks at the First Meeting of the Council (Jan. 17, 2002), available at http://www.bioethics.gov/about/chairman.html.

Fertility LifeLines, Initial Treatments, http://www.fertilitylifelines.com/initialtreatments/index.jsp (last visited Jan. 16, 2009).

American Pregnancy Association, In Vitro Fertilization: IVF, http://www.americanpregnancy.org/infertility/ivf.html (last visited Jan. 16, 2009).

E.g., Lisa Baker, A Surrogate Dries Her Tears, N.Y. TIMES, Dec. 11, 2005, available at http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/11/fashion/sundaystyles/11LOVE.html.

E.g., Katrina Clark, My Father Was an Anonymous Sperm Donor, WASH. POST, Dec. 17, 2006, at B01, available at http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/12/15/AR2006121501820.html.

Giovanni Frazzetto, DNA or Loving Care?, 5 EMBO REP. 1117, 1117 (2004).

–  –  –

characteristics in a fertilized egg7 or even “germline” genetic engineering at some point in the not-too-distant future.8 As can be imagined, such techniques and the possibilities that they create are infused with controversy. IVF can result in the creation of numerous embryos,9 many more than can ever be implanted in the mother, and arguments rage over the legal status of these fertilized eggs and what their eventual fate should be. Some people argue that the embryos should eventually be given over for adoption,10 and others argue that such embryos provide a promising source of cells for stem-cell research.11 IVF techniques can also result in multiple successfully implanted embryos, forcing parents to choose between selective abortion of some of the resulting fetuses so as to improve the chances of bringing the remainder to term or undergoing a risky multiple-birth pregnancy.12 Debate also swirls around the possibility of human-reproductive cloning, a process where an exact genetic duplicate of an already existing human being could be created.13 John A. Robertson, Extending Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis: Medical and Non-Medical Uses, 29 J.

MED. ETHICS 213, 213 (2003).

ASS’N OF REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROF’LS, HUMAN CLONING AND GENETIC MODIFICATION: THE BASIC

SCIENCE YOU NEED TO KNOW 5 (2003), available at http://www.arhp.org/uploadDocs/cloning.pdf#search="HUMAN%20CLONING%20AND%20GENETIC% 20MODIFICATION%20THE%20BASIC%20SCIENCE%20YOU%20NEED%20TO%20KNOW%20" (“‘Germline’ genetic engineering is genetic engineering that targets the genes in eggs, sperm, or very early embryos.... Germline engineering is banned in many countries but not in the U.S.”) Georgia Reproductive Specialists, In Vitro Fertilization (IVF-ET): Questions and Answers, http://www.ivf.com/ivffaq.html (last visited Jan. 16, 2009) (stating that “25% of pregnancies with IVF are twins” whereas in the “normal population, the rate one set of twins per 80 births”).





E.g., Nightlight Christian Adoptions, Nightlight Adoptions: Snowflakes Program, http://www.nightlight.org/snowflakeadoption.htm (last visited Jan. 16, 2009).

Liza Mundy, Souls on Ice: America’s Embryo Glut and the Wasted Promise of Stem Cell Research, MOTHER JONES, July/Aug. 2006, http://www.motherjones.com/news/feature/2006/07/souls_on_ice.html.

Ozkan Ozturk & Allan Templeton, Multiple Pregnancy in Assisted Reproduction Techniques, in

CURRENT PRACTICES AND CONTROVERSIES IN ASSISTED REPRODUCTION: REPORT OF A MEETING ON

“MEDICAL, ETHICAL AND SOCIAL ASPECTS OF ASSISTED REPRODUCTION” HELD AT WHO HEADQUARTERS

IN GENEVA, SWITZERLAND 17-21 SEPT. 2001 200, 220-21 (Effy Vayena et al. eds., 2002), available at http://www.who.int/reproductive-health/infertility/report.pdf.

Genomics.energy.gov, Human Genome Project Information: Cloning Fact Sheet, http://www.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/elsi/cloning.shtml (last visited Jan. 16, 2009).

–  –  –

Another controversial process involves the use of PGD not only to screen for inheritable diseases in a successfully fertilized egg but also to screen for other inheritable conditions such as eye color, gender, intelligence, or even perfect pitch.14 In addition, some couples have used ART, and PGD in particular, to intentionally produce disabled children. For example, a deaf, lesbian couple in the United States utilized IVF to increase their odds of having deaf children and have successfully given birth to two deaf children as a result.15 Another example includes a dwarf couple who wanted to use genetic testing to determine if they could have a child that would inherit their dwarfism.16 And in 2003, it was reported that a Chicago-area physician was approached by a couple that wanted the physician’s assistance in using PGD to enable them to give birth to a child with Down syndrome.17 The doctor refused, but in 2008, a study in an American medical journal revealed that of 137 clinics in the U.S. that provide IVF, three of them reported offering the procedure to prospective parents who sought to select for disabilities,18 demonstrating that not all doctors face an ethical quandary carrying out such a technique. Though such numbers indicate that the procedure is far from routine, this science is still in its earliest stages. It is not difficult to imagine a future in which the science is more advanced, where the technology exists to permit prospective parents to routinely utilize PGD to select for or against identifiable genetic conditions.

Robertson, supra note 7, at 214.

See Liza Mundy, A World of Their Own, WASH. POST, Mar. 31, 2002, at W22 (stating that the couple used a deaf sperm donor to increase their chances of having a deaf child and utilized IVF as a method of conceiving).

Peter H. Huang, Herd Behavior in Designer Genes, 34 WAKE FOREST L. REV. 639, 642 (2001).

Judith F. Daar, ART and the Search for Perfectionism: On Selecting Gender, Genes, and Gametes, 9 J.

GENDER, RACE & JUST. 241, 265 (2005).

Susannah Baruch et al., Genetic Testing of Embryos: Practices and Perspectives of US In Vitro Fertilization Clinics, 89 FERTILITY & STERILITY 1053 (2008); see William Saletan, Deformer Babies: The Deliberate Crippling of Children, Sept. 21, 2006, http://www.slate.com/id/2149854 (referring to an earlier survey with the same results).

–  –  –

B. A Survey of In-Vitro Fertilization and Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis ART, defined as any procedure that involves the handling of eggs or embryos,19 is several decades old in the United States. In this Article, the term will be used primarily to refer to methods of conception utilizing IVF, the means by which an egg is fertilized outside of the body and then implanted in a woman’s uterus.20 IVF was first developed in the late 1970s and early 1980s, and the first child produced via IVF was born in 1978 in England.21 The first child produced by IVF in the Untied States was born in 1981,22 and since then approximately one million babies have been born in this country utilizing IVF technologies.23 IVF is a four-step process that is performed over a month-long period.24 The first step involves the stimulation of the woman’s ovaries with hormones to induce the ovaries to produce several eggs at one time.25 The eggs are retrieved from the woman’s ovaries during a minor surgical procedure and placed in separate petri dishes, after which they are given two to five days (depending on the procedure) to be fertilized by sperm, which are also in the petri dishes.26 Once successful fertilization has taken place, the fertilized

AM. SOC’Y FOR REPROD. MED., ASSISTED REPRODUCTIVE TECHNOLOGIES: A GUIDE FOR PATIENTS 18

(2007), available at http://www.asrm.org/Patients/patientbooklets/ART.pdf.

Cooper Center for In-Vitro Fertilization, In-Vitro Fertilization, http://www.ccivf.com/in-vitro_fert.html (last visited Jan. 16, 2009).

Andrea L. Bonnicksen, In Vitro Fertilization and Embryo Transfer, in 4 ENCYCLOPEDIA OF BIOETHICS 2307, 2307 (3d ed. 2004); see Patrick Steptoe & Robert Edwards, Birth After the Reimplantation of a Human Embryo, 2 LANCET 366 (1978).

First IVF Child in U.S. Meets Doctor: Carr Finally Reunited with Obstetrician, MSNBC, Oct. 31, 2003, available at http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/3088015/.

PRESIDENT’S COUNCIL ON BIOETHICS, REPROD. & RESPONSIBILITY: THE REGULATION OF NEW

BIOTECHNOLOGIES 3 (2004), available at http://www.bioethics.gov/reports/reproductionandresponsibility/_pcbe_final_reproduction_and_responsibil ity.pdf.

See Bonnicksen, supra note 21, at 2307; Shared Journey—Your Path to Fertility, What Is IVF?, http://www.sharedjourney.com/ivf/what_is.html (last visited Jan. 16, 2009).

Bonnicksen, supra note 21, at 2307; see Shared Journey—Your Path to Fertility, Ovulation Induction, http://www.sharedjourney.com/articles/induc.html (last visited Jan. 16, 2009).

Bonnicksen, supra note 21, at 2307; Shared Journey—Your Path to Fertility, Embryo Culture, http://www.sharedjourney.com/define/culture.html (last visited Jan. 16, 2009).

–  –  –

eggs—comprised of four to sixteen cells depending on how long they have cultured in the dish—are then transferred to the woman’s uterus two to three days after they were removed.27 Anywhere from two to four embryos may be implanted in the woman’s uterus at the time of transfer in the hopes that one of the embryos will successfully attach to the uterus and begin the process of becoming a fetus.28 Any remaining embryos that are not implanted can be cryo-preserved either for later transfer or disposition, usually in accordance with the wishes of the couple or the woman receiving the IVF treatment.29 After twelve days, the woman returns for a blood test to determine if the embryo has successfully attached to the uterus and pregnancy has been initiated.30 Prospective parents with concerns about the presence of genetic conditions in their children were, in the past, limited to prenatal genetic diagnosis, consisting of one of two tests: (1) chorionic villus sampling, a procedure in which tissue from the placenta is extracted for examination, or (2) amniocentesis, a procedure that utilizes amniotic fluid containing small samples of fetal tissue.31 The greatest limitation of these procedures is the fact that neither test can be done until well after the embryo has been implanted in the uterus and developed into a fetus, usually about nine to eighteen weeks after implantation, while an embryo develops into a fetus generally about eight weeks after

Bonnicksen, supra note 21, at 2307; see Shared Journey—Your Path to Fertility, The IVF Process:

Embryo Transfer, http://www.sharedjourney.com/define/transfer.html (last visited Jan. 16, 2009) [hereinafter The IVF Process: Embryo Transfer].

Bonnicksen, supra note 21, at 2307; The IVF Process: Embryo Transfer, supra note 27.

The IVF Process: Embryo Transfer, supra note 27; see Bonnicksen, supra note 21, at 2307.

The IVF Process: Embryo Transfer, supra note 27.

Richard J. Tasca & Michael E. McClure, The Emerging Technology and Application of Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis, 26 J.L. MED. & ETHICS 7, 7 (1998); Familydoctor.org, http://familydoctor.org/online/famdocen/home/women/pregnancy/fetal/144.html (last visited Jan. 16, 2009) (explaining briefly the amniocentesis and CVS procedures).

–  –  –



Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |


Similar works:

«CONNECTICUT BAR EXAMINATION 27 July 2010 QUESTION #1 Doris, driving a sedan, sped through an intersection as the light was changing from yellow to red. She couldn’t stop her car in time to avoid Paul’s truck, which had entered the intersection from the cross street. Doris hit Paul’s car directly in the side, causing extensive damage. Charlie, a police officer, arrived at the accident scene about twenty minutes later and wrote a report. Now Paul, alleging negligence, has brought a civil...»

«California Law Review Vol. 90 December 2002 No. 6 Copyright © 2002 by California Law Review, Inc. Does the Evidence Favor State Competition in Corporate Law? Lucian Bebchuk,† Alma Cohen,‡ and Allen Ferrell†‡ Table of Contents Introduction I. Does Delaware Incorporation Increase Shareholder Value?. 10 A. Tobin’s Q Differences Between Delaware and Non-Delaware Corporations 1. The Current Nonexistence of Correlation 2. The Fluctuations of the “Delaware Effect” 3. The Problem of...»

«The Obsolescence of Environmental Common Law R. Trent Taylor* Obsolescence, the process of becoming obsolete, is a staple of our lives in the twenty-first century. As new and better technologies develop at a faster and faster pace, our existing technologies—smartphones, televisions, computers— become obsolete almost as soon as they are released to the public. Entire technologies, like the fax machine, emerge rapidly and then disappear just as quickly with the advent of a faster and easier...»

«RTX 5.1 The Real-Time Environment for Windows® ã 2001 VENTURCOM, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. VenturCom, Inc. Five Cambridge Center Cambridge, Massachusetts 02142 Phone 617-661-1230 No part of this document may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, graphic, electronic, or mechanical, including photocopying, and recording or by any information storage or retrieval system without the prior written permission of VenturCom, Inc. unless such copying is expressly permitted by...»

«OCTOBER 2015 IAWA NEWSLETTER in this issue: President’s Message Finding the right balance. Airbus Group’s answer A Spark of Innovation: Unbroken Cold Chain Design Textron: A leader in aviation Upcoming Events IAWA 27th Annual Conference IAWA-GCAA Young Women in Aviation Forum 2015 Women in Aviation and Aerospace Committee (WAAC) Conference Vaughn College Gala IAWA 28th Annual Conference Receptions and Connects Bogota Reception ALTA Reception Paris Connect Washington New Members Connect IAWA...»

«DBSJ 14 (2009): 99–107 A REVIEW ARTICLE New Testament Theology: Magnifying God in Christ Reviewed by Andrew David Naselli1 New Testament Theology: Magnifying God in Christ by Thomas R. Schreiner. Grand Rapids: Baker, 2008. 990 pp. $44.99. ABOUT SCHREINER Schreiner is James Buchanan Harrison Professor of New Testament Interpretation and Associate Dean of Scripture and Interpretation at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, Kentucky, where he has served since 1997. He earned...»

«Role of the Bench and the Bar By MR. JUSTICE MIRZA HAMEEDULLAH BEG Broad purpose of Bench and Bar The body of persons which operates the machinery through which justice is administered, composed mainly of the Judges and the Advocates who help them in discharging their difficult duties, has existed and functioned both in ancient and modern times. Its broad purpose throughout has been to realise all those goals which are labelled Justice” according to the law which has to be administered in a...»

«UNEP COMPENDIUM OF SUMMARIES OF JUDICIAL DECISIONS IN ENVIRONMENT RELATED CASES REVISED 2ND EDITION DRAFT REFERENCE DOCUMENT January 2015 UNEP Compendium of summaries of Judicial Decisions in Environment-related Cases2015 Revision INTRODUCTION This revised second edition and the first edition of the Compendium have been developed in response to requests made by Chief Justices and senior Judges of over one hundred countries who participated in the UNEP Global Judges Symposium on Sustainable...»

«IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF KANSAS No. 105,988 STATE OF KANSAS, Appellee, v. AARON ISREAL SALINAS, Appellant. SYLLABUS BY THE COURT Under the facts of this case, the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying the defendant's motion to depart from the hard 25 life sentence provided for in Jessica's Law, K.S.A. 21-4643, for a conviction of aggravated criminal sodomy with a child less than 14 years of age. Reasonable people could agree with the district court's determination...»

«Inferiority Complex: Should State Courts Follow Lower Federal Court Precedent on the Meaning of Federal Law? Amanda Frost* The conventional wisdom is that state courts need not follow lower federal court precedent when interpreting federal law. Upon closer inspection, however, the question of how state courts should treat lower federal court precedent is not so clear. Although most state courts now take the conventional approach, a few contend that they are obligated to follow the lower federal...»

«MEMORANDUM DECISION Pursuant to Ind. Appellate Rule 65(D), FILED this Memorandum Decision shall not be regarded as precedent or cited before any Dec 14 2016, 7:57 am court except for the purpose of establishing CLERK the defense of res judicata, collateral Indiana Supreme Court Court of Appeals estoppel, or the law of the case. and Tax Court ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE MOTHER Gregory F. Zoeller Attorney General of Indiana Renee M. Ortega Lake Superior Court, Juvenile Division...»

«Teatro do Mundo Linguagens Barrocas do Teatro Europeu Título Teatro do Mundo Linguagens Barrocas do Teatro Europeu Edição Centro de Estudos Teatrais da Universidade do Porto Execução Gráfica SerSilito – Maia Tiragem 500 exemplares Depósito legal 252749/07 ISBN 978-989-95312-0-8 Take, eat; this is my body – a few remarks on the banquet scene in Marlowe’s and Shakespeare’s tragedies Nuno Pinto Ribeiro Oporto University I. “Banquet scene” “trial scene”, “temptation...»





 
<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.thesis.dislib.info - Online materials, documents

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.