FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Online materials, documents

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 4 | 5 ||


-- [ Page 6 ] --

–  –  –

associations.188 For example, the American Medical Association (AMA) has addressed genetic enhancement, stating that it should generally be reserved only for therapeutic purposes and finding that enhancement to improve human traits is “contrary... to the ethical tradition of medicine.”189 The AMA has also found genetic selection for nondisease related traits to be unethical, stating that all procreative and gene therapies should be to “alleviate human suffering and disease by remedying disorders for which available therapies are not satisfactory.”190 Similarly, the World Medical Association has stated that physicians who provide assisted reproductive services “should always consider their ethical responsibilities toward any child who may be born as a result of the treatment” and that treatment should not be provided if serious harm to the child will result.191 Of course, despite the dim view that these professional associations take toward nontherapeutic uses of ART, only the willingness to enforce professional sanctions might prevent physicians who disagree with the associations’ views from utilizing PGD to enable parents to procure disabled children. Unfortunately, as the anecdotes referenced earlier make clear, that threat has not so far prevented isolated efforts.192 Lastly, there is the option of relying upon self-regulation on the part of prospective parents193 (an option that may be inevitable if constitutional challenges to the regulation of PGD are successful). This is simply another way of expressing reliance upon the belief that parents are better at deciding what is in their child’s best interest than

–  –  –

AM. MED. ASS’N, AMA CODE OF MEDICAL ETHICS: CURRENT OPINIONS WITH ANNOTATIONS, 2006Gene Therapy, available at http://www.amaassn.org/ama1/pub/upload/mm/Code_of_Med_Eth/opinion/opinion211.html.


World Medical Association, The World Medical Association Statement on Assisted Reproductive Technologies, at Preamble (adopted Oct. 2006), available at http://www.wma.net/e/policy/r3.htm.

See supra Part I.A.

See McConnell, supra note 49, at 60.

–  –  –

any other societal entity, including courts or legislatures. The viability of this notion seems premised on whether or not society is willing to tolerate the minority of parents who might not be acting in their child’s best interests or who act based on a flawed understanding of their child’s best interests in bringing disabled children into the world.194

–  –  –

As this Article has demonstrated, there are a variety of rationales that would support the regulation of PGD to prevent cases of intentional diminishment and a variety of means by which such regulation could be carried out. ART have provided great hope to individuals who would otherwise be unable to bear children. The study of the human genome has revealed great wonders about human diversity and holds the key to the eradication of dreaded genetic diseases. But, these technologies also give individuals the means to write their parental preferences into the DNA of their children. A survey of the issues reveals that society has a compelling interest in regulating the use of PGD to prevent intentional diminishment. This interest is premised on the need to act in the best interests of future children by protecting them from the harm that follows from being born disabled as a result of an exercise of their parents’ procreative preferences. But, whether the legislation necessary to further such interests would survive a constitutional challenge cannot be clear until legislation is passed by the states that specifically proscribes certain uses of PGD. For now, it seems the real effort lies in educating the public about the potential pitfalls of unregulated use of PGD so as to encourage reasoned debate over which uses are and are not appropriate and to avoid any regulatory overreactions that might follow after learning how the technology has already been put to

–  –  –

use. Only with such education and debate can society determine the amount of protection that we should accord children born from these procedures, the right of parents to utilize these procedures to further their procreative interests, and the potential consequences of

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 4 | 5 ||

Similar works:

«Expert Meeting Report: Transforming Existing Buildings through New Media An Idea Exchange Stacy Hunt Building America Retrofit Alliance (BARA) May 2012 NOTICE This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States government. Neither the United States government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, subcontractors, or affiliated partners makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy,...»

«TRAINING RESOURCES ON SEXUAL VIOLENCE: FREE AND LOW-COST TOOLS FOR CAMPUSES (PLUS SOME PRICIER ONES) 1 September 2014 INTRODUCTION Colleges and universities in the United States are reviewing and expanding their training and education on sexual assault. New federal laws, regulations, and agency guidance have inspired this work. Two federal sources have been particularly important. These are: (1) the 2013 amendments to the Violence Against Women Act, with section 304 known as the Campus SaVE...»

«RIGHTS, PRIVILEGES, AND THE FUTURE OF MARRIAGE LAW Adam J. MacLeod* INTRODUCTION On the occasion of its final triumph, has the cause of marriage equality fallen short? As the smoke clears from the Supreme Court of the United States’ decision in Obergefell v. Hodges, requiring states to extend legal marriage recognition to same-sex couples, the precise implications of the decision for state marriage laws are yet to be revealed.1 What is the future of marriage law in this new constitutional...»

«Marcus Evans Conferences, Corporate Fraud Strategy: Assessing the Emergence of Identity Fraud Sydney, 25-26 July 2002 ‘Examining the Legislative and Regulatory Controls on Identity Fraud in Australia’ Russell G. Smith Understanding the Range of Activities of Identity Fraudsters that Could Lead to Prosecution Misuse of identity lies at the heart of a wide range of criminal activities. These extend from relatively simple cases in which an individual gains access to a computer using someone...»

«COMMISSION ON LEGAL COUNSEL FOR INDIGENTS MINIMUM ATTORNEY PERFORMANCE STANDARDS JUVENILE UNRULY AND DELINQUENCY MATTERS Performance Standard 1.1 – The Objective and Function of the Performance Standards Performance Standard 1.2 Interpretation of the Performance Standards Performance Standard 2.1 Legal Training and Experience of Counsel Performance Standard 2.2 Other Training and Experience of Counsel Performance Standard 3.1 Accepting Appointments Adequate Time and Resources Performance...»

«Acting on our union with christ: romAns 6:12-23 ZAne c. hodges1 Therefore do not let sin reign in your mortal body so that you obey it with its lusts, neither turn over your body’s members as instruments for unrighteousness, but turn yourselves over to God as people who are alive from the dead, and turn over your body’s members to God as instruments for righteousness. For sin shall not have authority over you, because you are not under the Law but under grace (Rom 6:12-14).2 In view of the...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.thesis.dislib.info - Online materials, documents

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.