FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Online materials, documents

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |

«Good, Bad or Inevitable? The Introduction of CCPs in Securities Lending A White Paper on the issues, opportunities and implications for the ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Good, Bad or Inevitable?

The Introduction of CCPs in Securities Lending

A White Paper on the issues, opportunities and implications for the securities lending industry.

Authors: Andrew Howieson, Howieson Consulting and Roy Zimmerhansl, Zimmerhansl Consulting

Table of Contents


Executive Summary


Change in the Securities Lending Market

The CCP Paradigm

Purpose and Functionality of a CCP

CCP Risk Management

CCP Risk Mitigation

CCP Lines of Defence

CCP Post-Trade Services

CCPs in Securities Lending

CCP Development in the US Market

CCP Development in the European Market

The Requirements

Market Structure

Critical Functionality

Operational Efficiency

The Securities Lending CCP Providers

CCPs: The Value Proposition in Securities Lending

Arguments For and Against CCPs

CCPs: Conclusions and Recommendations

Leveraging the CCP Infrastructure

The Global Challenge

Appendix 1: CCPs Active in Securities Lending

Appendix 2:Potential impact on Securities Lending of Proposed BIS changes to Basel II......(Appendix) 5


The potential for introduction of Central Counterparty (CCP) services in the securities lending markets has been under discussion for a number of years. During 2009 those discussions became a reality and CCPs in the United States and in Europe have launched securities lending facilities in collaboration with electronic trading platform providers.

While these are significant early stage developments, broad adoption of CCP services in the securities lending industry remains some way off. Indeed, debate on the merits of CCP services continues throughout the industry. To date, the opposing arguments have resembled ships passing in the night, with a lack of independent analysis and little resolution.

The objective of this white paper is to provide independent analysis to the arguments for and against industry-wide adoption of CCPs. This is not an academic paper –rather, the intent is to bring a practical, business-driven approach to analysis of the opposing arguments. The paper draws on discussions with representatives of key securities lending market participants, CCPs active in securities lending and regulatory authorities. Where appropriate the paper references material drawn from the extensive range of technical analyses relevant to CCP facilities in securities lending markets.

This is a critical time for the securities lending industry as markets begin to recover from the credit crisis, transparency and risk management become imperatives, short-selling and related lending practices come under unprecedented scrutiny and institutional investors re-examine the opportunities and risks inherent in securities lending. The authors believe that time is no longer on the industry’s side and that the adoption of CCP services merits serious and timely evaluation in the context of developing securities lending markets.

Executive Summary

Central Counterparty (CCP) services have been introduced on both sides of the Atlantic, linked to electronic trading platform initiatives, but are some distance from broad adoption in securities lending and discussion continues throughout the industry on the merits of CCPs.

The introduction of CCPs in securities lending is in close alignment with the drivers of change in the industry:

increased attention to counterparty risk, tougher regulatory requirements in terms of capital allocation and balance sheet usage, new awareness of the costs to end users inherent in securities lending and regulatory concern over systemic risk and market supervision. CCPs do not directly drive improvements in market transparency and price formation but are supportive of electronic trading platforms through broadening trading market participation and providing post-trade anonymity.

Despite the demanding and product specific requirements of securities lending, CCPs are able to deliver the fundamental benefits for which they are designed, namely counterparty risk mitigation and improved operational efficiency. Optimisation of the CCP model in securities lending will require significant industry consultation and flexibility in application.

Proposed regulatory changes have made inevitable the broad adoption of CCPs in securities lending. Notably, proposed changes to capital adequacy guidelines in Basel III would present significant challenges to the existing securities lending business model and would inhibit growth in the industry. The broad adoption of CCPs in securities lending is not only inevitable but provides a major opportunity to reduce systemic risk, increase participant earnings and reduce the industry’s cost structure, while providing a foundation for sustained growth. Broad adoption of CCPs will contribute to growth in both electronic trading platform business and in bilateral OTC securities lending as the business will become less resource intensive allowing both to flourish in a growing marketplace.

This paper is targeted at a number of parties. The findings should be of interest to firms looking:

 To generate incremental returns through a wider distribution network;

 For a more efficient market where they can achieve more with fewer resources;

 To reduce balance sheet and capital utilised in the conduct of securities finance business;

 To reduce overall industry risk whilst improving market efficiency;

 To be strategic thinkers looking towards the future rather than remaining rooted in the past.

While considerable uncertainty remains around the specifics of CCP adoption in securities lending, the introduction of CCPs presents an opportunity for competitive advantage, particularly to Agent Lenders and Principal Borrowers able to work with Beneficial Owners and End Borrowers to optimise their participation and to transfer significant lending volumes from a bilateral to a centrally cleared environment. Substantial use of CCPs can sit comfortably alongside bilateral business allowing the overall market volume to grow without placing unnecessary burdens on firm resources. The securities lending industry needs to be proactive in determining the optimal CCP configuration and working with CCP providers to achieve broad implementation.


Securities lending has often been described as a “back-office” or operational function. Certainly, the origins of organised securities lending in the 1970s owes more to expediting settlement and the development of an ancillary custodial service and less to an investment management or trading market discipline. Responding to the securities industry’s accelerating demand for borrowed securities to cover settlement failures and to support investment strategies involving short-selling, custodian banks commenced the development of organised lending programs which developed into key revenue generating divisions supported by significant operational, administrative and business resources.

In understanding the current dynamics of the securities lending markets and the debate over the introduction of CCP facilities, it is important to contrast the development of securities lending as an arrangement between the custodian banks (as well as a limited number of direct lenders) and the leading broker-dealers with the investment and trading led development of equities, fixed income and other securities markets. Securities lending still comprises primarily a series of bilateral relationships rather than a marketplace as is standard in equity, fixed income and derivatives markets.

To a degree, securities lending has moved toward recognition as an investment management discipline. A number of institutional investors have recognised lending as a significant source of alpha revenue generation and worked with custodian agents and third-party agents to develop lending programs geared toward their specific investment objectives and disciplines. This positive development has accelerated following evidence of lack of awareness of and involvement in the detail of lending programs by some beneficial owners demonstrated in the 2008-9 fallout from the credit crisis, particularly related to cash reinvestment programs.

The industry is currently experiencing heightened beneficial owner awareness and involvement which is expected to bring securities lending closer to broad alignment with investment management disciplines and heightened awareness of trading practices in securities lending.

If securities lending programs in general have moved toward investment management disciplines, trading itself has remained essentially a series of bilateral arrangements between agent lenders and major brokerdealers. These arrangements have been influenced by factors not found in other trading markets, including “ratio lending”, the linkage between take-up of GC (general collateral or readily available securities) and availability of Specials (or hard to borrow securities).

The continuing emphasis on bilateral arrangements between agent lenders and major broker-dealers (essentially the prime brokers) shapes the characteristics of the current trading market and exerts a profound influence on the debate over development of CCP facilities in securities lending.

Change in the Securities Lending Marketplace

There is no question that Securities Lending has developed into a major global market with linkages to securities and derivatives markets worldwide. At year-end 2009, lendable equity assets were estimated at $

5.3 trillion globally, with an estimated $700 billion on loan. While still substantial, these numbers reflect a reduction of almost 50% from the lending market peaks experienced in 2007.

Change has come slowly to the securities lending market which has always been regarded as “different”.

Electronic trading platforms have been introduced in the US (Quadriserv) and in Europe (SecFinex) and have made headway in their respective markets. However, bilateral relationships between the custodian agents and the prime brokers continue to dominate the trading aspects of securities lending, contributing to a

number of generally recognised deficiencies when compared to other markets:

1. The absence of a central order book and of centralised transaction reporting leads to a lack of transparency, affecting beneficial owners and end borrowers. Pricing is inefficient and reflects high intermediary costs resulting from the necessity of manual search and maintenance of multiple counterparty credit arrangements.

2. Given the thousands of beneficial owners supplying securities and the thousands of end user hedge funds and proprietary traders borrowing securities, the bilateral trading focus of the current market for securities lending results in a concentration of counterparty exposure among a limited number of major prime brokers and agent lenders. Generally, such a pronounced lack of diversification is of increasing regulatory concern, best evidenced by the recent moves focused on penalising large counterparty exposure through extra capital provisioning. The market has evolved into a structure which is viewed by some as oligopolistic in nature.

3. The lack of a central market place for securities lending contributes to high operational and technology costs in the industry. Operational functions such as collateral valuation and maintenance, administration of recalls and returns, monitoring and processing of corporate actions can reasonably be expected to be more cost-efficient in a centralised market environment rather than in a series of parallel processing environments. Even with the increased use and penetration of external vendor reconciliation services, there is no doubt that increased standardisation and availability of “golden” figures from a CCP can be expected to lead to improved operational and reconciliation processes.

4. Securities lending is an OTC business on a global scale, with limited direct oversight of trading markets. Regulatory oversight is particularly difficult to accomplish in a diffused trading market with no central data repository. In times of market stress this difficulty in monitoring securities lending transactions has contributed to regulators’ decisions to impose blanket restrictions on securities short selling activities and can be expected to influence further regulatory controls.

5. Business volumes have decreased substantially from the heights reached in 2007 with an estimated fall by as much as 50%. This has added pressure for market participants and contributed to the focus for many firms to cut back rather than invest for the future.

If change has always come slowly to securities lending, a series of differing but related factors is now driving an accelerated demand for change in the industry.

First, a result of the credit crisis has been a reappraisal of the risks and rewards inherent in securities lending.

Beneficial owners are increasingly focused on maximising the intrinsic value of earnings from securities lending and aware of the risks inherent in generating large volumes of lending in order to receive cash for reinvestment purposes. This renewed focus on intrinsic earnings argues in favour of a transparent, competitive marketplace with efficient pricing and best execution standards.

Second, a further result of the credit crisis, exacerbated by the Lehman default, is an increased focus on counterparty risk. Concerns over the measurement and management of counterparty risk are broad and global in nature, with particular scrutiny of risks arising from OTC businesses including derivatives, repurchase transactions and securities financing. The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) Consultative Document “Strengthening the resilience of the banking sector”, issued in December 2009, is explicit: “The risk coverage of the capital framework will be strengthened....the strengthened counterparty capital requirements are designed to increase incentives to move OTC derivative exposures to central counterparties and exchanges”.

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |

Similar works:

«Department of Homeland Security Management Directive System MD Number: 0540 Issue Date: 09/30/2004 OFFICIAL RECEPTION AND REPRESENTATION FUNDS I. Purpose This directive establishes policies, assigns responsibilities, and prescribes procedures governing the use of appropriated funds for official reception and representation (ORR) purposes throughout the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). II. Scope This directive applies to all DHS Organizational Elements (OE). III. Authorities A. Department...»

«Review: Focus on form Review: Doughty, C., & Williams, J. (1998). Focus on form in classroom second language acquisition. New York: Cambridge University Press. Takeshi Matsuzaki November 20, 1998 1. Introduction This volume, building on relevant theoretical claims and research findings, discusses in depth the efficacy and ways of implementing focus on form (FonF)1, namely, drawing learner attention to some particular linguistic features during primarily communicative second language activities....»

«RTFO Guidance Part Three: Guidance for Verifiers RTFO Year 7: 15 April 2014 to 14 April 2015 Version 7.0, April 2014 The Department for Transport has actively considered the needs of blind and partially sighted people in accessing this document. The text will be made available in full on the Department’s website in accordance with the W3C’s Web Content Accessibility Guidelines. The text may be freely downloaded and translated by individuals or organisations for conversion into other...»

«FOR PUBLICATION UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT  UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, No. 10-30056 Plaintiff-Appellee,  D.C. No. v. 2:08-cr-00404RAYMOND ERIKSEN, JCC-1  Defendant-Appellant.  UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, No. 10-30057 Plaintiff-Appellee, D.C. No.  v. 2:08-cr-00404JCC-2 SIGMUND ERIKSEN,  Defendant-Appellant. OPINION Appeals from the United States District Court for the Western District of Washington John C. Coughenour, District Judge, Presiding Argued and...»

«Language, Information and Computation (PACLIC12), 18-20 Feb, 1998, 118-126 English Nasal-Final Prefixes and Uniform Exponence* Seok-keun Kane Wonkwang University The purpose of this paper is to reconsider the phonology of English nasal-final prefixes within the framework of Optimality Theory, especially making use of a relation of correspondence. In this paper, I show that compared with previous analyses employing rules and their extrinsic orderings, a constraint-based approach can give a...»

«Unscheduled Care Redirection Guidance Document V14 Redirection Guidance Document Introduction A National Unscheduled Care Expert Group (UCEG) was established in the spring of 2013 to identify priorities for action for NHS Scotland and to make formal recommendations to bring about improvements to the quality of Unscheduled Care in line with the 2020 vision. The Group is made up from clinical and Professional Experts in Unscheduled Care, including representatives from the CEM, RCN, RCS, RCP, RCGP...»

«Shakespeare's Globe Research Bulletin Issue Number 19 March 2001 The 2000 Globe Season The Red Company The Two Noble Kinsmen By Dr Jaq Bessell (Globe Research) The Two Noble Kinsmen The Red Company, 2000 CONTENTS Dramatis Personae/The Red Company 2 Setting 4 Costume 5 Music 6 Scenes in Rehearsal 7 Act I 7 Act II 11 Act III 17 Act IV 22 Act V 24 THE TWO NOBLE KINSMEN Dramatis Personae, The Red Company THESEUS, DUKE OF ATHENS Martin Turner HIPPOLYTA, QUEEN OF THE AMAZONS, LATER WIFE OF THESEUS...»

«NURIOOTPA HIGH SCHOOL Tradition—Relationships—Excellence P 8562 2022 E dl.0788.admin@schools.sa.edu.au F 8562 1029 W www.nurihs.sa.edu.au FROM THE PRINCIPAL Welcome to term 4 and finally some sunny weather!! Once again we look forward to a busy term with many events and opportunities for learning. Term 4 is also full of celebrations and new adventures. We wish all of our Stage 2 students the very best as they complete their assessments, prepare for exams and finalise their secondary...»

«University of Colorado, Boulder CU Scholar Undergraduate Honors Theses Honors Program Spring 2013 Does Music Predictability Improve SpatialTemporal Reasoning? Jared Konner University of Colorado Boulder Follow this and additional works at: http://scholar.colorado.edu/honr_theses Recommended Citation Konner, Jared, Does Music Predictability Improve Spatial-Temporal Reasoning? (2013). Undergraduate Honors Theses. Paper 415. This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by Honors Program...»

«Curriculum Vitae G.K. BALASUBRAMANI Department of Epidemiology 1800, Pioneer Drive University of Pittsburgh Sewickley, PA 15143 127 Parran Hall, 130 DeSoto Street U.S.A. Pittsburgh, PA 15261. U.S.A Phone: (412)-648-2625 Fax: (412)-624-3775 Phone:(412)-367-1422 Email: balagk@edc.pitt.edu Education: DEGREE YEAR(s) FIELD OF STUDY INSTITUTION AND LOCATION Presidency College, India B.Sc. 1984 Statistics University of Madras, India M.Sc. 1986 Statistics University of Madras, India M.Phil. 1987...»

«WYNDHAM COLLEGE STUDENT HANDBOOK Nirimba Education Precinct Eastern Road Quakers Hill NSW 2763 Phone: 9208 7100 Fax : 9208 7199 The Wyndham Way – More than Just an Education Wyndham College Address: Nirimba Education Precinct, Eastern Rd, QUAKERS HILL NSW 2763 Phone: 9208 7100 Fax: 9208 7199 Email: wyndhamcol-h.school@det.nsw.edu.au Website: http://www.wyndhamcol-h.schools.nsw.edu.au Or follow us on Facebook Office Hours: Monday – Thursday 7.30am to 3.00pm, Friday 7.30am to 2.30pm....»

«DOE–LM/GJ625–2004 ESL–RPT–2004–04 Environmental Sciences Laboratory Analysis of Contaminant Rebound in Ground Water in Extraction Wells at the Tuba City, Arizona, Site April 2004 Prepared for U.S. Department of Energy Grand Junction, Colorado Work Performed Under DOE Contract No. DE–AC01–02GJ79491 for the U.S. Department of Energy Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. ESL–RPT–2004–04 Analysis of Contaminant Rebound in Ground Water in Extraction Wells at the...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.thesis.dislib.info - Online materials, documents

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.