FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Online materials, documents

Pages:     | 1 | 2 || 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |

«Good, Bad or Inevitable? The Introduction of CCPs in Securities Lending A White Paper on the issues, opportunities and implications for the ...»

-- [ Page 3 ] --

Figure 5 CCP Market Structure Figure 5 (above) illustrates the choices presented to market participants in a CCP supported securities lending market.

Beneficial Owners are generally expected to rely on Agent Lenders to provide access to CCPs as an integral part of the lending service. However, the proposed Eurex Clearing service to the bilateral OTC market anticipates offering a Specific Lender Licence, available only to Beneficial Owners (although Agent Lenders would operate on behalf of Specific Lender licence holders). Holders of Specific Lender Licences will not be required to provide margin nor contribute to the CCP’s Guarantee Fund provided that the Specific Lender Licence holder maintains collateral received against securities loans within the CCP.

Agent Lenders (both custodian and third-party agents) have the choice of becoming Clearing Members, with direct access to the CCP, or of accessing the CCP through a General Clearing Member (Clearing Member in the US).In practice, the majority of the major Agent Banks are likely to operate through affiliated entities extending existing CCP participation to the securities lending service, thus benefiting from the CCPs’ low risk weighting.

Principal Borrowers (major prime brokers/ broker-dealers) are likely to already be CCP members through securities trading business lines and are expected to extend or add memberships to cover securities lending and benefiting from the CCPs’ low risk weighting.

End Borrowers are expected to access securities lending CCPs, in most cases, through their prime brokerage relationships. In some instances the end borrowers may acquire Non Clearing Member status, allowing direct trading access under a General Clearing Member (US Clearing Member) responsibility. However, major Hedge Funds meeting CCP membership requirements may be expected to take Clearing Member status on a direct basis.` It should be noted that the favourable treatment proposed under Basel II revisions for counterparty credit exposures within a CCP environment (0% risk weighting) apply to Clearing Members only (as they contract direct with the CCP). Thus in order to benefit from this treatment, market participants must become a Clearing Member. This will inevitably impact market participants’ decisions on whether to access a CCP directly or through a General Clearing Member/Clearing Member.

2. Critical Functionality

Unlike the purchase or sale of equities or fixed income securities where the clearing function is completed and final within a few days, securities loans are extended term transactions (almost entirely of open duration) with a series of ongoing obligations through the life of the loan and a “closing” as well as an “opening “transaction. As the counterparty to all member transactions, the CCP must treat all open loans as “pending contracts” until the closing transaction and effectively guarantee performance against the obligations of the loan.

Figure 6 (below) depicts the key functionality required from CCPs in securities lending. CCPs are positioned to offer guaranteed payments in respect of collection of increased collateral, of (manufactured) dividends and of loan fees /rebates. This ability represents an enhancement to market practice and a potential benefit to agent lenders that contractually fund clients irrespective of counterparty settlement and beneficial owners whose lenders apply actual settlement accounting.

Figure 6 Key Functionality for CCPs in Securities Lending

3. Operational Efficiency While the ongoing loan performance guarantee is a significant commitment, the potential to centralise the operational processes required to service that commitment represents a major opportunity to create post-trade efficiencies. The extent to which a CCP provides post-trade services beyond the minimum level required to meet the CCP’s performance guarantee may be considered optional but has significant implications for CCP’s potential to improve the general operational efficiency of the securities lending marketplace.

In the US securities lending market, collaboration between the CCP (Options Clearing Corporation), the electronic trading platform (Quadriserv AQS), the Central Securities Depositary (DTC)and the dominant US order routing and “books and records” system (SunGard’s Loanet) has produced an integrated link facilitating loan initiation and modification, settlement, mark to market processing and transaction reporting. The automated processing provided through the Loanet collaboration means that loans executed through AQS/OCC are subject to the same straight through processing (STP) treatment as OTC executions, creating significant efficiencies for users. Additionally, a further development from Loanet will allow access to the AQS electronic trading platform directly from the Loanet application (alongside order routing capabilities), facilitating consistent treatment of AQS/OCC and OTC business throughout the pre-trade, trade and post-trade lifecycle.

4. The Securities Lending CCP Providers

There are currently three CCPs active in the securities lending markets and one in development.

Options Clearing Corporation (US), LCH Clearnet and SIS x-clear in Europe all are operating live CCPs.

Eurex is developing CCP functionality for European markets. Appendix 1 profiles each of the CCPs.

CCPs: the Value Proposition in Securities Lending In this section we examine the principal arguments for the introduction of CCP services in the securities lending market and where applicable the contra arguments, review the value proposition for the key market constituents and analyse the fit with the fundamental drivers of change in the securities lending industry.

Arguments For and Against CCPs

1. Mitigation of Counterparty Credit Risk One fateful week in mid-September 2008 saw an actual borrower default (Lehman) and an agent lender (AIG, acting as agent for AIG principal entities) need rescuing by the US government. That same week also saw several other leading prime brokerage organisations extremely stressed and there were real concerns that other defaults would follow shortly thereafter. The first action of many market participants was to reduce the number of counterparty relationships they dealt with and to cut lines for those relationships where they did continue. While on the face of it this seems a reasonable approach, upon further examination it seems counter-intuitive. How can the right approach to reducing counterparty risk simply be to concentrate exposure to a smaller group of entities? Only firms that had eliminated Lehman risk prior to its default could make a claim to knowing which firms could be considered “safe” counterparties that they could continue to trade with.

In the reduced counterparty scenario, it is likely that the percentage of a firm’s securities lending business each remaining counterparty represented would be an increase over the pre-Lehman period, reinforcing the concentration risk. This is inconsistent with common practice whereby when firms merge, existing credit lines are not aggregated. Rather, the new credit line would be less than the sum of the two previous lines. In that way the new merged entity would represent a reduced percentage of the overall business exposure, even where the larger firm could be considered “stronger”.

The two approaches – one concentrating risk, the other attempting to reduce firm risk, are at odds with each other.

The CCP takes a different approach. By widening the universe across the larger community and ensuring transaction level margining, CCP usage allows firms to indirectly increase their counterparty network and mutualise the risk across a wider audience.

The proposed modifications to Basel II, published by the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) and likely to be fully adopted by the G13 member countries refer specifically to “exposures arising from derivatives, repos and securities financing activities” and state “the strengthened counterparty capital requirements are designed to increase incentives to move OTC derivative exposures to central counterparties and exchanges”.

In the securities lending context, use of a qualified CCP allows for replacement of bilateral counterparty credit risk with the equivalent of AAA risk for all Clearing Member exposures.

Some Agent Lenders have argued in favour of bilateral credit exposures on the basis that the ability to select counterparties on a bilateral basis allows them to deal only with counterparties they consider credit worthy while CCP membership creates an (indirect) exposure to names they may not consider credit worthy. This argument is unconvincing for two reasons: first, under the bilateral model credit exposure has been increasingly concentrated with a limited number of major counterparties and renewed market growth will be difficult to accommodate within this model while the degree of concentration runs contrary to accepted risk dispersal theory. Second, CCPs are specifically designed to mutualise and mitigate risk, as explained in the CCP Paradigm section of this paper. CCPs deploy (typically) six lines of defence against a Clearing Member default and, in contrast to a bilateral arrangement, are structured to actively manage risk exposure to Clearing Members and to take clearly defined remedial action as soon as a Clearing Member fails to meet margin or other commitments. For this reason qualified CCPs are treated as AAA rated entities for counterparty risk purposes.

Introduction of CCPs to securities lending provides an opportunity to convert significant amounts of bilateral credit exposure to the equivalent of AAA rated exposure. Counterparty credit lines are a scarce resource and credit line utilisation has been a hot topic for both lenders and borrowers for many years, exacerbated by the Lehman default. CCPs allow participants to reduce credit line utilisation and have the opportunity to benefit from increased trading opportunities. There are three areas where CCPs bring value to this aspect of every firms business and a fourth that applies to borrowers.

 Better use of existing credit lines. As the CCP becomes the zero (or close to zero)risk weighted counterparty to all novated transactions, no credit lines are used. This leaves credit availability for transactions that are agreed bilaterally or to be used by other business lines of the firm.

 In a bilateral environment where credit lines are full, firms would simply cease trading. The CCP scenario gives market participants the ability to continue to trade.

 Where no credit lines exist – either as a result of a specific choice not to engage in trading, or where firms have no relationship, users of CCPs can trade.

 Where firms have traditionally been essentially borrowers, the opportunity to become lenders with a single (or few) CCPs as counterparty, with little or no balance sheet or capital costs, offsetting collateral necessary for borrowing activity and capturing an additional revenue spread on top becomes compelling.

2. Capital Allocation and Balance Sheet Usage The proposed revisions to Basel II referred to above present major challenges to the current securities lending business model. Appendix 2 illustrates the scope of the proposed changes to Basel II relevant to securities lending and includes a hypothetical example of potentially significantly increased Capital Allocation requirements for securities lending transactions.

The introduction of CCPs to the securities lending market provides an opportunity to convert significant amounts of bilateral credit exposure to a 0% (or close to 0%) risk weighted environment, with a significant positive impact on Clearing Members’ capital adequacy. As illustrated in Appendix 2 this positive impact is likely to be significantly greater given the implementation of Basel III in its proposed form. While the example presented in Appendix 2 is necessarily hypothetical (as advanced approaches require knowledge of the individual circumstances of firms making the calculations), it is illustrative of the extent to which Basel III can be expected to challenge the current securities lending model. There is no question that regulators want to see as much bilateral exposure as possible moved to CCP environments and the Basel III proposals are supportive of that objective. The move toward a 0% (or at most 1-3%) risk weight may eliminate the effect of differing exemptions to risk weight allocation models granted by regulators, reducing resulting regulatory arbitrage and potentially increasing acceptance of the CCP model.

Similarly, the introduction of CCPs to securities lending potentially offers significant advantages to Clearing Members in terms of balance sheet usage, with the potential to record amounts receivable /payable to a CCP on a net basis (this is after the position and margin netting carried out by the CCP), freeing balance sheet capacity for use in increased securities lending or other business activities.

It should be noted that, in the US market, broker-dealers ability to offset receivables against payables on securities loans novated to a CCP for financial reporting purposes is dependent on confirmation of extension of Financial Accounting Standards Board ( FASB) Accounting Standards Codification section 815-10-45 (formerly FASB Interpretation No.39) to include securities loans in addition to repurchase agreements and derivative transactions.

Securities lending contracts are generally not considered as derivative instruments under FASB definitions.

However Quadriserv has advanced the case, in a written submission to the FASB, that when securities lending transactions are cleared through a CCP operating a master netting agreement, resulting receivables and payables should be treated in the same way as payables/receivables associated with derivative instruments and be similarly eligible for offset in financial reporting.

Pages:     | 1 | 2 || 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |

Similar works:

«Oxford Poverty & Human Development Initiative (OPHI) Oxford Department of International Development Queen Elizabeth House (QEH), University of Oxford OPHI Research in Progress series 2011 This paper is part of the Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative’s Research in Progress (RP) series. These are preliminary documents posted online to stimulate discussion and critical comment. The series number and letter identify each version (i.e. paper RP1a after revision will be posted as RP1b)...»

«43 T H E P R I E S T IN COMMUNITY By K E V I N KELLY F COURSE, the big difference is that unlike religious we O diocesan priests are not b o u n d by vow to living in c o m m u n i t y. W e have a very different spirituality. W e have to be able to live alone'. T h e words are mine; the sentiments are those of most diocesan priests. S o m e t h i n g equivalent to this is said every time the issue of c o m m u n i t y is raised a m o n g diocesan priests. In reality, a diocesan priest without...»

«Analysis of effectiveness of state funding of combined transport Stanislav Kutacek, Jana Vlckova Transport Research Centre Brno, Czech Republic [Stanislav.Kutacek@cdv.cz] On Saturday 19th June 2004 the operation of RO-LA1 line Lovosice [CZ] – Dresden [D] was cancelled. After ten years of running project was stopped that should have meant shift from road freight transportation to less environmentally damaging rail freight transportation on this route. There is no doubt that road freight...»

«The Entry, Performance, and Viability of De Novo Banks* Yan Lee Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Washington, DC 20429 Chiwon Yom Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Washington, DC 20429 September 9, 2014 Please do not cite without authors’ permission. Abstract De novos are of interest as they represent the beginning of a community bank’s life cycle. From 2000 to 2008, 1,042 new banks were chartered, mostly in large, rapidly growing regions, with incumbent banks focused on...»

«INSTITUTE OF PHYSICS PUBLISHING JOURNAL OF PHYSICS: CONDENSED MATTER J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 15 (2003) 4361–4369 PII: S0953-8984(03)55916-1 Automatic construction, implementation and assessment of Pettifor maps Dane Morgan1, John Rodgers2 and Gerbrand Ceder1 1 Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Department of Materials Science and Engineering, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA 2 Toth Information Systems Inc., 2045 Quincy Avenue, Gloucester, K1J 6B2, Canada E-mail:...»

«WORK IN FREEDOM International Labour Office Geneva HUMAN TRAFFICKING FOR JAPAN SEXUAL EXPLOITATION IN SAP-FL Special Action Programme to Combat Forced Labour Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work Foreword Worldwide, more and more attention is now being given to the problem of trafficking in human beings. Indeed, almost no country in the world is exempt from the new and unacceptable forms of forced labour and sexual exploitation associated with human trafficking. Three years...»

«Town of Chester – Board of Selectmen Meeting – June 25th, 2009 Town of Chester BOS Meeting June 25th, 2009 Town Hall Approved Minutes I Preliminaries 1.1 Call to Order Chairman Hassam called this meeting of the Town of Chester Board of Selectmen to order at 7:00pm.1.2 Roll Call Selectmen present: Joe Castricone James Hassam Stephen Landau Selectmen absent: Robert Brown Jack Cannon Members of the Public present, at various times: Rich Antoine, Fire Chief Aaron Berube, Police Sergeant Bill...»

«                  MODULE  3  RECAPS       This  material  belongs  to  King  Jesus  International  Ministry.     We  authorize  you  to  DISTRIBUTE,  RESEND  and     GIVE  OUT  these  notes  to  the  most  amount  of  people  posible,     so  that  this  information  may  edify  the  entire  body  of  Christ!                   SESSION 1 Rebellion Against Authority Apostle Guillermo...»

«The Unbelievable Will Soon Begin-Are You Prepared to Receive It? I am dedicating this article to my beloved and treasured wife of 55 years whose life began a new life for me. An event happened some time during my 17 years as a 24/7 care giver when I asked God, “Why has my love for my wife expanded, increased, enlarged or radically become positively different?” God’s answer forever changed my life, “You have discovered your wife needs you and this should be the same reason you love Jesus...»


«Page 1 Out, Damn Spot: The Physical Impact of Thinking Dirty Kellie Fitzgerald “Out, damn'd spot! out, I say!—One; two: why, then 'tis time to do't.—Hell is murky.—Fie, my lord, fie, a soldier, and afeard? What need we fear who knows it, when none can call our pow'r to accompt?—Yet who would have thought the old man to have had so much blood in him?” William Shakespeare, Macbeth I type on a keyboard that has never been cleaned, and I wonder why. It is the dirtiest thing I have...»

«schoolondersteuningsprofiel Schoolondersteuningsprofiel Ibn-i Sina schoolondersteuningsprofiel Inhoudsopgave 1. Inleiding 2 2. Algemene gegevens 3 2.1 Contactgegevens 3 2.2 Onderwijsvisie 5 2.2.1 Schoolconcept 5 2.3 Kengetallen leerlingenpopulatie huidig schooljaar 6 en de afgelopen 4 schooljaren 3. Basisondersteuning 7 3.1 Basiskwaliteit van het onderwijs 7 3.2 Planmatig werken 8 3.3 Preventieve en licht curatieve interventies 8 3.4 Onderwijsondersteuningsstructuur 9 4. Ondersteuningsprofiel...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.thesis.dislib.info - Online materials, documents

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.