FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Online materials, documents

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 85 | 86 || 88 | 89 |   ...   | 121 |


-- [ Page 87 ] --

1. Research Goals We will investigate the following questions:

15TH Annual Conference on Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education 425

1) What is the relationship between the written, spoken and gestural text of a lecture and the students’ written text of their notes? What do students include in their notes and how do they decide what to write?

2) Viewing the lecture as a text, who is the implied reader of this text, the actual readers and what is the relationship between them?

2. Theoretical Perspective We will adapt the theoretical framework described by Weinberg and Wiesner (2011), who applied ideas of literary criticism to describe factors that impact the ways students read and understand mathematics textbooks. The two concepts we will use are those of the implied reader and reading models.

The implied reader of a mathematics text is the “embodiment of the behaviors, codes, and competencies that are required for an empirical reader to respond to the text in a way that is both meaningful and accurate” (Weinberg & Wiesner, 2011 p. 52). The behaviors of the implied reader are “sequences of actions (physical or mental) enacted by the implied reader” (Weinberg & Wiesner, 2011 p. 52). For example, the implied reader of the lecture might actively think about previous examples and theorems and trying to make connections with what they are currently observing. The codes of the implied reader are the ways that the implied reader interprets the language, symbols, words, gestures (etc.) that are part of the lecture. For example, a lecturer might say (and write): “Let G be a group….” ; the implied reader might interpret the word “group” as an algebraic object and recognize G as the standard symbol to represent it.

Finally, the competencies are the “mathematical knowledge, skills, and understandings” to understand the text (Weinberg & Wiesner, 2011 p. 55). For example, the implied reader might know what a group is and be familiar with the axioms that are related to the mathematical context in which the group is being discussed.

The empirical reader of a mathematics text is the person who is attempting to interpret the text—in this case, the students in the class. The students’ reading models—their strategies for reading and and beliefs about their role in a classroom shape the transaction between the students and the lecture. Weinberg and Wiesner (2011) describe two key types of beliefs that affect students’ strategies. Students who have a text-centered model “believe that they are receivers of meaning” (Weinberg & Wiesner, 2011 p. 56); they may be likely to try to transcribe aspects of the lecture as literally and “accurately” as possible for later memorization and replication. In contrast, students who have a reader-centered model if they think of their participation in the lecture—even if it is passive—as a meaning-making process; these students may be likely to be selective about the aspects of the lecture that they record and construct their own interpretations of important aspects of the lecture.

3. Methods Data is being collected on an on-going basis in an introductory abstract algebra class during the Fall 2011 semester. The instructor self-identifies as a traditional teacher who uses lecture as his principal in-class pedagogical technique and maintains nearly complete control over the content.

Classroom observations. Approximately seven class meetings will be observed and video recorded throughout the Fall 2011 semester. Field notes will focus on the relationship between gestures, speech, and the text written on the board. Thus far two class meetings have been observed and recorded. The  observations  will  be  selected  to  capture  a  variety  of  typical   426 15TH Annual Conference on Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education lecture  content  (including  the  introduction  of  a  new  concept,  a  proof ­writing  episode,  and   working  of  a  homework ­type  problem)  and  a  variety  of  presentation  formats  (including   episodes  where  the  instructor  discusses  an  idea  without  writing  on  the  board  and  an   episode  where  the  instructor  writes  ideas  on  the  board  non ­linearly.   All of the instructor’s talk and board work during the relevant portion of the lesson will be transcribed—including the order in which the board work was developed—and all gestures will be described. We will construct tables with 3 columns to describe the written text, spoken text and described gestures.

Analysis of classroom data. Data will be coded in two distinct manners that will then be synthesized during analysis. First, each piece of text will be analyzed to explicitly describe the mathematical meaning that it conveys to an expert reader, including a description of any explicit links to mathematical ideas from outside the lecture. Each of these pieces will be marked for the expert observers’ perception of the instructor’s emphasis of importance. In order to describe the implied reader, we will create a set of notes that capture a possible “expert” observer’s explanation of content, mental habits, and required competencies for learning advanced mathematics that incorporates all aspects of the text. Some specific aspects of analysis include describing the requirements in terms of symbols, proof-skills, knowledge of examples and properties, and the various verbal, symbolic, and gestural codes. Finally, we will compare and contrast the aspects of the implied reader across the different aspects of the text (written, spoken and gestural) to describe the barriers and supports to understanding the mathematics that these different aspects may provide.

Data from students. Seven students will participate in this study. We will collect their classroom notes from the observed course meetings and assess their understanding of the relevant content with a written instrument. We will conduct semi-structured interviews with each student them about their note-taking habits and beliefs about their role in a lecture-based classroom, and ask them to give a short summary of how they use their notes as part of doing homework and preparing for exams.

Prior to conducting each interview, we will identify excerpts where the student’s notes differed from what the instructor wrote on the board, what the instructor said, or the gestures that the instructor used; these excerpts will be used during the interview to prompt discussion. The

interview will include the following questions:

1. How do you take notes in this class? For  you  personally,  what  is  the  purpose  of  taking   notes  in  this  class?  

2. How do you plan to use your class notes?

3. [Using  a  video  clip  where  the  instructor  attempted  to  convey  a  difficult  idea  or   example:]  Was  there  something  in  [this  video  clip]  that  you  felt  was  difficult  for  you  to   take  notes  on?   4. [Using a video clip where there was (or wasn’t) something in the lecture—verbal, written, or gestural—that wasn't recorded in the notes:] How come you didn't (or did) record this aspect of the lecture in your notes?

5. [Using  an  example  where  the  board  work  isn’t  developed  linearly:]  What  aspects  of  this   part  of  the  class/lecture  do  you  think  are  significant?  What  aspects  did  you  decide  to   capture  in  your  notes?     Analysis of student data. The analysis of the students’ notes will focus on differences and similarities between the text of the lecture (as described by the “expert” observers) and the students’ notes. We will identify the implied reader of the lecture and use this construct to try to 15TH Annual Conference on Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education 427 understand some of these differences. For example, the course instructor may rely on various proof heuristics—such as an “onto proof”—and we will describe whether these heuristics are part of the implied reader, whether the students’ notes are guided by this heuristic, and whether the students’ notes and their interview responses indicate that the underlying codes are meaningful to them. In addition, we will compare the students’ notes across types of episodes (definitions, examples, etc.) and during instances where the board work is not developed linearly to understand and characterize the implied reader.

We will also characterize the students’ reading models and use these to interpret patterns in their note-taking habits and the extent to which their notes match the written part of the lecture-text.

4. Proposed discussion questions:

1) What would you most want to know about how students take notes?

2) What are the benefits and drawbacks of framing this study using the ideas of the implied reader and reading models? What critiques would you offer?

3) Is this a fruitful line of inquiry for mathematics education? Given our interest in nonlecture-based classes, is the RUME community interested in this focus of research?

4) The implied reader of a mathematics lecture may very well be different from the empirical readers. As a result, using this framework for analysis will very likely portray lecturers as “out of touch” with their students. What kinds of things should we be thinking about and doing in order to help ensure the continued engagement of our colleagues with research that they might see as adversarial to their teaching practices?

428 15TH Annual Conference on Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education


Bligh,  D.  (2000).  What’s  the  use  of  lectures?  San  Francisco:  Jossey ­Bass.   Davidson,  N.,  &  Gulick,  F.  (1976).    Abstract  algebra,  an  active  learning  approach.  Boston:   Houghton  Mifflin.     Dubinsky,  E.,  &  Leron,  U.  (1994).    Learning  abstract  algebra  with  ISTEL.    New  York:   Springer ­Verlag.   Johnstone,  A.  H.,  &  Su,  W.  Y.  (1994).  Lectures ­  a  learning  experience?  Education  in   Chemistry,  31(1),  75 ­76,  79.   Kiewra,  K.  A.,  DuBois,  N.,  Christian,  D.,  McShane,  A.,  Meyerhoffer,  M.,  &  Roskelley,  D.  (1991).   Note ­taking  functions  and  techniques.  Journal  of  Educational  Psychology,  83  (2),   240 ­245.   Larsen,  S.  (2004).    Supporting  the  guided  reinvention  of  the  concepts  of  group  and   isomorphism:  A  developmental  research  project.    Unpublished  Doctoral   Dissertation,  Arizona  State  University.   Mejia ­Ramos,  J.,  Weber,  K.,  Fuller,  E.,  Samkoff,  A.,  Search,  R.,  Rhoads,  K.  (2010).  Modeling  the   comprehension  of  proofs  in  undergraduate  mathematics.  Proceedings  of  the   Conference  on  Research  in  Undergraduate  Mathematics  Education,  Raleigh,  NC.     http://sigmaa.maa.org/rume/crume2010/Archive/Mejia ­Ramos%20et%20al..pdf   Weinberg,  A.  &  Wiesner,  E.  (2011)  Understanding  mathematics  textbooks  through  reader ­ oriented  theory.  Educational  Studies  in  Mathematics  76  (1),  49 ­63.   Weinberg,  A.,  Wiesner,  E.,  Benesh,  B.,  &  Boester,  T.  (2011)  Undergraduate  students'  self ­ reported  use  of  mathematics  textbooks.  PRIMUS.  Retrieved  from   http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10511970.2010.509336.  

–  –  –

Category: Preliminary Research Report Abstract: Many studies exist on student difficulty transferring mathematical knowledge to physics, on student understanding of trigonometry, and student ability to create graphical representations of functions. However, there are no studies that exist in the intersection of these issues. This study sought to explore student understanding of simple harmonic motion by examining how their approach to graphing the sine and cosine functions impacted their ability to graph sine and cosine based models of simple harmonic motion. The findings of this study conclude that neither an object perspective or process perspective of the graphical representations of sine and cosine is sufficient for the ability to graph simple harmonic motion modeled based on cosine. There seems to be an element missing, a connection students must make between the changes in input type, that needs to be addressed in order for students to create a graphical representation of a cosine-based simple harmonic motion model.

Keywords: student understanding, trigonometric functions, simple harmonic motion, graphical representations

Author information:

Gillian Galle Mathematics and Statistics, University of New Hampshire get7@wildcats.unh.edu 430 15TH Annual Conference on Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education 1 Introduction and research questions Many students find physics, both algebra and calculus-based, to be a challenging subject.

This may be in part due to some of the difficulties that students experience when they are expected transfer their mathematical knowledge to models of various physical concepts, such as simple harmonic motion. Several studies have sought to describe these difficulties by studying students’ abilities to transfer knowledge of algebra and calculus concepts to applications within physics (Cui, et. al., 2006; Ozimek, et. al., 2004). Students that are enrolled in algebra-based physics may face additional difficulties with this transfer the equivalent of a high school algebra course is often the only prerequisite to taking the course.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 85 | 86 || 88 | 89 |   ...   | 121 |

Similar works:

«STOXX LTD. / CFA SOCIETY GERMANY SMART BETA: THE 360° OVERVIEW THE SPEAKERS AND TOPICS SARA SHORES, CFA, Managing Director, Head Investment Strategy for BlackRock’s Factorbased Strategies Group and the Global Head of Smart Beta Sara Shores, Managing Director, is the Head Investment Strategy for BlackRock’s Factorbased Strategies Group and the Global Head of Smart Beta, driving the strategy innovation and thought leadership for Smart Beta and all factor-based strategies for institutional,...»

«Ex-post Evaluation of 2007 & 2008 European Capitals of Culture Executive Summary Project Director: Dr Andrew McCoshan Project Manager: James Rampton Evaluation Team: Jonathan France, Thijs Viertelhauzen, Ana Zsok Ex-post Evaluation of 2007 & 2008 European Capitals of Culture Executive Summary C4013 / July 2009 ECOTEC Quay Place Vincent House 92-93 Edward Street Birmingham B1 2RA T +44 (0)121 212 8800 F +44 (0)121 212 8899 www.ecotec.com Executive Summary Introduction The European Capital of...»

«Photocatalysis: Fundamentals, Materials and Potential Edited by Pierre Pichat Printed Edition of the Special Issue Published in Molecules www.mdpi.com/journal/molecules Pierre Pichat (Ed.) Photocatalysis: Fundamentals, Materials and Potential This book is a reprint of the Special Issue that appeared in the online, open access journal, Molecules (ISSN 1420-3049) from September 2014–August 2015 (available at: http://www.mdpi.com/journal/mo lecules/special_issues/photocatalysis ). Guest Editor...»

«COMPARISON OF SERVICE LIFE OF A RIVETED STEEL RAILWAY BRIDGE UNDER DIFFERENT OPERATING SCENARIOS MD Shafiul Azam Supervisors: Professor Dr. Raffaele Landolfo and Assistant Professor Dr. Mario D'Aniello Thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements For the Degree of Master of Science in Construction of Steel and Composite Structures European Erasmus Mundus Masters Course Sustainable Construction Under Natural Hazards and Catastrophic Events University of Naples “ Federico II”...»

«OS QUINHENTOS MILHÕES DA BEGUN JÚLIO VERNE Edição de Anastasiya Basova Dalila Santos Maria Inês Bico Patrícia Fitas Sofia Rodrigues Coordenação de Ângela Correia Lisboa ÍNDICE Nota Editorial O livro-fonte Normas de transcrição Bibliografia OS QUINHENTOS MILHÕES DA BEGUN I. Em que Mr. Sharp apparece em scena II. Dois collegas III. Uma noticia IV. Contas ao meio V. A Cidade do Aço VI. O poço Albrecht VII. O Corpo Central VIII. caverna do dragão IX. A fuga X. Um artigo da Unsere...»

«Summary of Faith What a Christian Should Believe and Practice Ignorance in matters of religion is one of the most fatal evils of our times. In all classes of society there are found, in large numbers, Christians who hardly know the principal truths of salvation, or who have but a vague and confused knowledge of them, intermingled with errors and prejudices. If they are reminded of the obligation which they have of learning the mysteries of faith, their indifference makes them reluctant to hear...»

«L-Shares: Rewarding Long-term Investors1 by Patrick Bolton Columbia University and Frédéric Samama SWF Research Initiative and Amundi – Crédit Agricole Group November 2012 Abstract: We argue that a fundamental reason for the short term perspective of corporate executives is the short-term orientation of shareholders and financial markets that drive the performance benchmarks of CEOs. In our view, long-term committed shareholders can provide substantial benefits to the company they invest...»


«REGISTERED BUILDING CONFIRMATION NAME: The Old School House ADDRESS: Cronkbourne Village, Braddan POST CODE: IM4 4QH LOCAL AUTHORITY: Braddan Parish Commissioners GRID REF: 370 776 Introduction Cronkbourne Village in Braddan was created by William Fine Moore during the mid-nineteenth century, in order to accommodate the families employed at his nearby Tromode Sailcloth Factory. The village comprises the Old School House (which was a community hall containing the school room and chapel), a...»

«563 Urban Transport XVIII Only-Bus System for intercity mass transit to reduce several numerous road traffic accidents P. E. Faye, H. Azuma & I. Yoshida School of Urban Environmental Sciences, Department of Tourism, Tokyo Metropolitan University, Japan Abstract Senegalese intercity mass transit is dominated by very dilapidated minibuses and unsafe buses and the main roads are not in a good condition for either daytime or night time driving. During the rainy season, many roads are passable only...»

«“Big” Triumph Rear Hub Rebuild Notes Background This project commenced as a result of my need to rebuild a rear hub on a 72 TR6. I learned subsequently that the roller bearing assembly was used on all “large” Triumphs from the TR2 though to the 2.0/2.5 saloons. In consequence, I believe that the following will be of interest to all the owners of all big Triumphs when attempting a hub rebuild. I should stress that the references apply only to a 72 TR6. I should also add that the task was...»

«The ‘Colorful’ Revolution of Kyrgyzstan: Democratic Transition or Global Competition? Yilmaz Bingol* This paper aims to analyze the reasons behind the recent revolution of Kyrgyzstan. I will argue that explaining the revolution through just the rhetoric of “democracy and freedom” needs to be reassessed, as comparing with its geo-cultural environment; Kyrgyzstan had been the most democratic of Central Asian republics. Thus, the paper argues that global competition between US and...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.thesis.dislib.info - Online materials, documents

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.